How to Choose a Trustee: Questions to Ask Before You Decide

Picking the person or firm who will manage your trust is one of the most personal choices in estate planning. If you are wondering how to choose a trustee, the best place to start is not with a name. It is with questions. What will the trust need? What will your family need? And can the person you have in mind actually do the job, possibly for many years?

This guide gives you a set of practical questions to work through, organized in the order many people find helpful. Members Trust also outlines four key considerations, time, responsibility, expertise, and cost, in its article on how to choose a trustee.

Start With the Trust: What Will the Job Require?

Different trusts need different kinds of trustees. Before thinking about people, think about the work.

How long will the trust last?

A trust that distributes everything soon after your death is a shorter job. A trust for young grandchildren, or for a loved one with special needs, may last decades.

What will the trust hold?

Cash and investment accounts are one thing. Real estate, a family business, or other unique assets can add complexity.

How much judgment is involved?

Some trusts have simple rules, like "distribute everything at age 30." Others give the trustee discretion over distributions for health, education, and support. Discretion calls for good judgment and careful records.

How many beneficiaries are there?

More beneficiaries can mean more communication, more requests, and more chances for disagreement.

Then Think About Your Family

The best trustee on paper may not be the best fit for your family.

  • Do family members get along? If there is tension, a neutral trustee may help reduce conflict.

  • Is there a blended family? Children from a previous marriage and a current spouse may have different interests.

  • Does a beneficiary need protection? Someone with special needs, creditor issues, or limited financial experience may benefit from careful oversight.

  • Will naming one child over another cause hurt feelings? Sometimes a neutral choice avoids that problem.

Questions to Ask About Each Trustee Candidate

Once you have a sense of the job, evaluate each person or firm you are considering.

Do they have the time?

Trustees handle record-keeping, tax coordination, investment oversight, and beneficiary communication. A busy professional or a parent of young children may find it hard to keep up.

Can they stay objective?

Ask yourself honestly whether the person can say no to a sibling or a close relative when the trust's terms require it.

Do they have the right skills?

Consider their comfort with finances, paperwork, deadlines, and working with attorneys and accountants.

Where do they live?

Distance matters less than it used to, but managing real estate or meeting beneficiaries may be harder from far away. Some states also have rules about out-of-state trustees.

How old are they, and what is their health?

If the trust will last 30 years, a trustee who is close to your own age may not be able to serve the whole time.

Are they willing?

Many people are named as trustee without being asked. Talk with your candidate before you finalize the document.

Questions to Ask a Trust Company

If you are considering a professional trustee, these questions can help:

  • What roles do you serve in? Trustee, co-trustee, agent for trustee, executor.

  • How are you regulated? Members Trust Company, for example, is a federal thrift regulated by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency.

  • Who will be my family's primary contact?

  • How do you review distribution requests?

  • What are your fees, and what do they include?

  • Will you work with my current financial advisor and attorney?

You can see how Members Trust describes its trustee roles on the Trust & Estate Services page.

Do Not Forget About a Successor Trustee

Choosing a successor trustee is just as important as choosing the first one. Ask:

  • Who will step in if my first choice cannot serve?

  • Should there be more than one backup?

  • Who has the power to appoint a new trustee if all named trustees are unavailable?

  • Could a trust company serve as a final backup?

A trust without a clear succession plan may need court involvement to appoint a new trustee, which can add time and cost.

Options That Blend Family and Professional Help

You may not need to choose just one path.

  • Co-trustee: a family member and a trust company serve together, combining "both professional management and decision-making input from family," as Members Trust describes it.

  • Agent for trustee: a family member is trustee, and a trust company helps with administration behind the scenes.

  • Trust protector or advisor: some trusts name a separate person with limited powers, such as removing and replacing a trustee. Ask your attorney if this fits your plan.

Who Members Trust Company Serves

Members Trust Company is "a national trust and wealth management firm with the heart of a credit union." It is owned by credit unions, has roots going back to 1987, and serves individual investors, credit union executives, financial advisors, legal or financial professionals, and current clients.

Its national headquarters is in Tampa, Florida, with offices in Denver, Colorado; Fairfax, Virginia; and Las Vegas, Nevada. Its team includes professionals with credentials such as JDs, LLMs, CFAs, CFPs, and CTFAs. Learn more on the About Us page.

Talk With Members Trust About Choosing a Trustee

If you are deciding who should manage your trust, a conversation can help you weigh your options. Schedule an introduction with Members Trust Company. Fill out the form and the team will be in touch shortly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is the best person to choose as trustee?

There is no single answer. Consider someone with time, objectivity, relevant skills, and willingness to serve for as long as the trust may last.

Should I name my child as trustee?

It can work well, especially for simple trusts and families that get along. Consider whether naming one child could cause conflict, and whether they have the time and skills.

Can a beneficiary also be the trustee?

Often, yes, but it can create conflicts of interest and may affect tax or creditor planning. Ask your attorney before naming a beneficiary as sole trustee.

Should I have more than one trustee?

Co-trustees can share the work and balance perspectives. They may also slow decisions if they disagree. Consider how decisions will be made.

What is a successor trustee?

A successor trustee steps in when the current trustee dies, resigns, becomes incapacitated, or is removed. The trust document usually names one or more.

Can I change my trustee later?

If your trust is revocable, you can usually change the trustee by amending it. For an irrevocable trust, it depends on the document and state law.


Trust Services provided by Members Trust Company, a federal thrift regulated by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. Members Trust Company non-deposit investment products are not credit union or bank deposits or obligations of, or guaranteed or endorsed or otherwise supported by, Members Trust Company, any credit union or any affiliate, are not federally insured or guaranteed by the United States Government, National Credit Union Administration, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Federal Reserve Board or any other governmental agency, and are subject to investment risks, including possible loss of the principal amount invested. This article is for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended to provide legal or tax advice regarding your situation. Nothing in this article should be construed as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and no strategy can guarantee any outcome. For legal or tax advice, please consult your attorney and/or accountant.

Trust services provided by Members Trust Company, a federal thrift regulated by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. Trust and Investment products are not NCUA/NCUSIF/FDIC insured. May lose value including the possible loss of principal. No financial institution guarantee. Not a deposit of any financial institution. This is for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide legal or tax advice regarding your situation. For legal or tax advice, please consult your attorney and/or accountant.

Previous
Previous

What Are Trust Services? A Simple Guide to Trustee, Executor, and Agent Roles

Next
Next

MTC Market Minute